"Innovation isn't just a new product, it's a new idea." Dustin Hinz on selling the feeling first

This issue first went out to subscribers of The Ad Podcast newsletter. Get the next one in your inbox, free: adpodcast.beehiiv.com
Dustin Hinz wanted to be a musician, and he had no backup plan. He got his first guitar at 14, went to as few classes as he could and still graduate, and finished high school at 17. His parents told him to get a job or go to school, and started charging him rent right away. His mom was the executive assistant to Guitar Center's CEO, so he begged her for a job. She gave him one in the mail room, just for the summer.
He stayed almost 19 years. The mail room was next to the marketing department, and he kept hanging around until he realized what they were doing was just an extension of what he wanted to do: tell stories and make art. He was in marketing by 18. Over his time there, Guitar Center went from roughly 25 stores to more than 300. Then, after a stretch at Ernie Ball, David Walker hired him as CMO of Firestone Walker, the brewery behind 805. David told him he had enough beer people around him. He wanted someone who understood lifestyle brands.
What stuck with me, as someone who sells for a living, is how Dustin explains what Guitar Center was really selling.
The big idea: sell the feeling before the product
Dustin calls music a hero worship business. People pick up a guitar because someone inspired them, whether it's Led Zeppelin or an uncle playing at a backyard barbecue. So if you want to sell the most instruments, the number one thing you can do is get people excited about wanting to play music.
That's why Guitar Center built a content machine long before most brands did: in-store sessions with great artists, then a YouTube channel, then a TV show. DIRECTV took 20 episodes of Guitar Center Sessions, starting with Peter Gabriel. It became the foundation for documentaries, podcasts and a syndicated radio show. Dustin carried the same thinking to 805, which he describes as the most globally recognized, regionally available beer brand.
This is the trap most sellers fall into. We pitch the product when the buyer is buying what it will feel like to have it. Start with what they want to happen, and the product becomes the obvious way to get there.
3 things to do about it
1. Translate brand into your buyer's math
Even with a hit show, Guitar Center's CEO kept asking about ROI. So Dustin broke it down: hundreds of hours of global broadcast television that would have cost around $35 million to buy as media, on a show DIRECTV was spending about $3 million a year to produce. And the CEO still asked how it drove sales.
His advice: have a phenomenal relationship with your CFO, and be fully aligned with your CEO. Selling brand can't be a dog and pony show. You need real data and the math that shows the work moves the needle.
This week: take your biggest open deal and put the value in a number the buyer's CFO already uses: cost per customer, media you replace, hours saved. If you can't, the deal isn't ready for the CFO.
2. Give partners a reason to choose you, not just a price
Dustin is honest that, in a category with Heineken and AB InBev, someone could outbid Firestone Walker without a problem. So the goal is partners who want to work with them because they believe in the same things. They stay in for the long haul. They've been with motocross rider Tyler Bereman for close to 10 years.
He pointed to Red Bull, which stood by Tyler through a serious injury when plenty of brands would have exercised an injury clause and moved on. That's what standing for something looks like in practice.
Sellers will always meet a cheaper competitor. The way to win anyway is to be the partner they'd pick even if they could pay less.
This month: write down the three things you won't do for a client, even to close a deal. If you can't name them, your buyer can't either.
3. Show them the beer
805 is unpasteurized, which is why it ships in amber bottles that protect it from light. For 805 Cerveza, the team wanted people to see how light and refreshing it was, and brewmaster Matt Brynildson found a way to do it without compromising how the beer is brewed. They moved it into clear bottles, and sales went up 20%. That led to their first TV spots with the beer shown in color against a black-and-white world.
Sellers spend a lot of time describing the product. Often the faster path is to let the buyer see it.
Next pitch: swap one slide that describes your work for the work itself: a live demo, a real campaign, or a customer on the call.
Bonus: read the room
Firestone Walker compared what people drank at rodeos and at music festivals. Consumption was nearly the same, but the products were completely different. 805 was the top seller at the rodeo. At a college music festival, their newer, flavor-forward Mind Haze outsold 805 three to one. Dustin also reminded me that people 45 and up are still about 60% of the beer business, even with everyone chasing Gen Z. The same pitch won't land in every room, and the newest audience isn't always the biggest one.
Best line of the episode
"Innovation isn't just a new product, it's a new idea." (Dustin Hinz)
Watch the full conversation
We also get into making a Super Bowl commercial with Questlove, why Guitar Center bought TuneCore to help artists get around the major labels, the guerrilla South by Southwest show they pulled off after their permits got pulled, how 805's non-alcoholic beer fits from paddle-out to podium, and why Firestone Walker's taprooms are temples to the brand.
Watch the full episode on Spotify. Also on Apple Podcasts and YouTube.
Want the next one? Every issue takes one conversation from The Ad Podcast and turns it into ideas you can use. Subscribe free at adpodcast.beehiiv.com.
Talk soon,Dylan




Comments