top of page
Search

14,000 agencies, one pitch. How Quality Meats cuts through

Writer: Dylan Conroy
Dylan Conroy
1 hour ago
3 min read

This issue first went out to subscribers of The Ad Podcast newsletter. Get the next one in your inbox, free: adpodcast.beehiiv.com

I've known Jonathan King since his Deutsch days. He's spent his career at eight agencies, from account intern all the way to managing director, and he's now Head of Growth at Quality Meats Creative, the Chicago indie that's done Super Bowl work for GoDaddy and Manscaped.

When he came on the show, he said something every agency seller should have taped to their monitor:

"There are 14,000 advertising agencies in the US. Everyone's kind of saying the same thing." (Jonathan King)

Human insights. Bold, distinctive work. Driving results. Every credentials deck says it. Which means none of them do.

The big idea: cut the fat

Quality Meats is named for the neighborhood butcher, not the supermarket counter. The butcher knows who you are and what you usually buy, trims the fat, and hands you the best cut. Jonathan says the agency's whole model comes down to one line:

"We want to get rid of all the bad stuff that gets in the way of getting to the good stuff." (Jonathan King)

The bad stuff is the swirl, the bloat and the layers that water ideas down at big holding companies. The good stuff is the work, and the relationship with the client. From where I sit, that's not just a creative philosophy. It's a sales one. Every layer between you and the buyer is a place where the deal slows down or dies.

3 things to do about it

1. Invite the client into the sausage making

Quality Meats doesn't do the big-reveal pitch. Clients are pulled into the process as equal stakeholders across several working meetings. That's how they won Super Bowl work for Manscaped. The deals that close fastest are the ones where the buyer helped build the answer.

Next pitch: replace one presentation meeting with a working session.

2. Sound like yourself, everywhere

On LinkedIn, every agency celebrates in the same polite voice. Quality Meats shows up colorful, a little weird, and consistent, using their own advertising methodology on themselves: be distinct or be ignored.

This week: delete every phrase in your deck and LinkedIn About that a competitor could also say.

3. Sell longevity, not deliverables

So much of their business comes from previous clients, connections, and friends of friends. "It's not about transaction, it's not about delivering deliverables. It's about really building that relationship."

This quarter: count how many of your last 10 wins came from relationships, then check whether your calendar matches.

Bonus: use AI to cut friction, not ideas

AI handles recaps, research and fast visualization, not the idea itself. That drone shot of a car in the mountains has no performance in it; if AI can do it, that's budget back for the parts that need humans.

Best line of the episode

"When you have that level of trust and connection and relationship, that is how business is done. That's how you keep business. That's how you win business." (Jonathan King)

Watch the full conversation

Learn more about Jonathan's agency at qualitymeatscreative.com.

Want the next one? Every issue takes one conversation from The Ad Podcast and turns it into ideas you can use. Subscribe free at adpodcast.beehiiv.com.

Talk soon,Dylan

 
 
 

Comments


(323) 420-6250

©2026 by Dylan Conroy

bottom of page